Tankless water heater models heat water only as it flows, while a tank keeps a full load of water hot all day. A tank is easier when several people shower at once, and a tankless unit uses less energy and saves space. If you live in Peterborough and want help with the choice, this guide covers the main points.
How Each Type Works
A hot water heater tank is the most common type in Canadian homes. It keeps the water hot all the time, so hot water is ready when you turn on the tap. That also means it uses energy even when nobody is using hot water. A tank also has a metal rod inside that is used up over time, so read about tank upkeep to keep it working.
A tankless unit has no tank. It heats the water as it passes through, with an electric element or a gas burner. Natural Resources Canada says these units most often use less energy than tanks, but they can fall short when the family needs several showers at the same time. In a hard freeze, any heater depends on the pipes that feed it, so read about cold-weather limits.
Canadians use 75 litres of hot water a day on average. Heating it takes 19.3% of the energy in the average home, second only to heating the house.
Gas Or Electric

Both tanks and tankless units come in gas and electric models. An electric hot water heater runs on power alone. A gas water heater burns gas. In Ontario, the TSSA is the safety body that certifies gas technicians, and gas work is their job. For a closer look at electric models with no tank, or help with your fuel choice, read those guides before you buy.
If you smell gas or your gas heater is not working, call a certified gas technician. Do not try to fix it yourself.
An ENERGY STAR gas tank uses 9% less energy than a standard gas tank. You can also save energy by wrapping the hot and cold pipes within two to three metres of any water heater.
Heat Pump Models
A heat pump water heater pulls heat from the air around it, often in a basement or utility room, and puts that heat into the water. An ENERGY STAR model uses up to 70% less energy than a standard electric tank.
It cools the room as it works, so you need less air conditioning in summer. In winter, when the house needs heat, it helps less. To see if one suits your basement, and what rebate it may get, read about heat pump options.
Price And Running Cost
There is no single tankless hot water heater price. A model that uses less energy can cost more up front. You earn that back over time through lower bills.
An ENERGY STAR tankless unit saves 30% more energy than a standard model. Ask for a written quote for each type, with the install included, before you choose. Before you count on a rebate, read about help with the bill.
Renting Instead Of Buying
In Ontario, you can buy a water heater or rent one. A business cannot sell or rent you a water heater at your door unless you asked it to come. Do not trust a salesperson who says your heater is unsafe.
If you sign a new water heater rental, you must end the old one, and there may be fees. Read the contract first, because some rental payments are still due if you cancel.
Which Type Fits Which Home
A tank suits a family that often runs several showers at once. If your hot water use is spread out through the day and you want to save space and energy, a tankless unit is the better fit. Look at a heat pump model if you have a basement or utility room with space around the heater. For the full list of gains and losses, read our guide to weighing the trade-offs. If you only need hot water at one sink, look at small units at one tap. When you are ready to change over, read about swapping a tank.
Either way, ask a plumber to size the heater for your home, and hire a licensed pro to put it in. If your heater is leaking now, go to urgent help.
Is A Hot Water Tank Cheaper Up Front?
We found no published prices to compare. A model that uses less energy can cost more up front, and it pays that back on your bills. Get a written quote for each type.
Can I Rent A Water Heater In Ontario?
Yes, you can. Ontario lets you buy or rent one, but a business cannot sell or rent you a water heater at your door unless you asked it to come.
Does Tankless Mean Endless Hot Water?
It comes close. Natural Resources Canada says a tankless unit gives close to endless hot water as you need it. It can still run short if several showers run at the same time.