Electric water heater vs gas is a choice about venting, power cuts and the fuel you can get. Electric models need no vent and are easy to put in. Gas models need a vent and air to burn, and some give hot water in a power cut. Here is how to compare the two for a home in Peterborough.
Electric Models
Electric models come in many sizes. They need no venting, and they are easy to install.
They have two limits. They cannot make hot water during a power cut, and a tank takes quite a bit of time to heat back up once you use it up.
Gas Models
Gas models come in many sizes and types. The vent can run through a chimney or a wall. If the heater has a pilot light that stays lit, it can still give hot water in a power cut. A gas heater needs enough air around it to burn the fuel.
Propane models have the same pros and cons, but propane costs more as a fuel.
Any gas work, from the install to a repair, belongs to a certified gas technician. If you smell gas, do not touch the heater, and call for help.
Which Costs Less To Run
We found no public figure in dollars for each fuel in Ontario. The cost to run a heater depends on four things: its size, its type, the fuel and how efficient it is.
You do not have to use the same fuel that heats your house. Natural Resources Canada calls that a choice, not a rule, and says to compare the fuels you can get where you live.
Use the labels to compare. On a gas heater, a higher energy factor means a more efficient unit. The EnerGuide label on some heaters lets you compare energy use with similar models.
What The Labels Tell You
An ENERGY STAR gas tank uses 9% less energy than a standard gas tank. A plain electric tank cannot get the ENERGY STAR mark at all.
An electric heat pump model is a different story. It uses up to 70% less energy than a standard electric tank. Read about heat pump models if that interests you. To compare tank and tankless, see the pros and cons.
If your tank is leaking now, it cannot be repaired. Go to urgent help.
Does A Gas Heater Work In A Power Cut?
It can. A gas heater with a pilot light that stays lit can still give hot water when the power is out. An electric heater cannot.
Do I Have To Use The Same Fuel As My Furnace?
No, you do not. It is a choice, not a rule, so compare the fuels you can get in your area.
Can I Install A Gas Heater Myself?
No, you should not. Gas work in Ontario is for a certified gas technician.