East City Plumbing

How To Repair A Broken Toilet Flange

East City Plumbing

How to repair a broken toilet flange comes down to one rule: if the flange is cracked or damaged, you replace it. The flange is the ring on the floor that holds the toilet to the drain. Sealant is not a safe fix for a crack. If you live near Peterborough, here is how to tell if yours is the problem and what the job involves.

Signs The Flange May Be The Problem

A toilet that rocks at the base can point to the floor or the flange. A worn wax seal under the toilet can cause it too. Loose bolts at the base are another cause, so check them first.

If the bolts are tight and the toilet still moves, the toilet has to come off so you can see the flange. If water shows up between the tank and the bowl instead, read about a leak between the tank and bowl.

Take The Toilet Off

Put on gloves and eye protection before you start. A toilet is heavy, so lift it with 2 people.

  1. Turn off the water valve behind the toilet.
  2. Flush, and hold the handle down to drain the tank.
  3. Sponge out the water left in the tank.
  4. Put a bucket under the tank, and take off the water line.
  5. Use a plunger to push out the water left in the bowl.
  6. Take off the bolt caps, and loosen the nuts with a wrench.
  7. Lift the toilet straight up, and set it to the side.

For more on getting the water out first, read about emptying the toilet.

Check The Flange

Stuff a rag into the drain hole. It keeps sewer gas in and keeps things from falling down the pipe. Then scrape the old wax off the top of the flange.

Look closely for cracks or damage. If you find any, the flange must be replaced with a new one. The guides we read give no steps for taking out the old flange, so have a plumber do that part.

Measure The Flange Height

Set the toilet on the bare flange first to see if it sits flat, and then lift it off again. Measure how far the top of the flange sits above or below the finished floor, because the right seal depends on that height in inches.

One guide we read uses 1/2 inch above the floor as its dividing line. If the flange sits 3/8 inch or more below the floor, you may need a thicker seal and longer bolts.

Set The Toilet Back

Once the flange is sound, take out the rag and put in new bolts and a new seal. Set the toilet on the seal, and check that it lines up. If the floor is uneven, use shims so the toilet sits flat.

Tighten the nuts a little at a time, switching from one side to the other. Do not overtighten, because that can crack the porcelain. If the bolts stick up too far, trim them with a hacksaw.

Hook up the water line, and turn the water on slowly. Flush a few times and watch the base for leaks. If you plan to caulk around the base, leave the back open so a leak can show.

Can I Seal A Cracked Flange?

No, you should not. The maker's guides we read say a cracked or damaged flange must be replaced, and they advise against sealant.

Why Does My Toilet Rock?

It can be the floor, the flange or a worn wax seal under the toilet. Loose bolts at the base can cause it too.

Should I Caulk Around The Base?

The guide we read advises against it, because caulk can hide a leak. If you do use it, leave the back open.

Request A Visit

Tell us what you see and when it started, and say if water is still running, so we know how soon you need help.

Read how we handle your details in our privacy policy.

Online requests are not open yet.